3. SIMILARITIES IN PROPAGATION OF LIGHT AND SOUND WAVES
The speed of light is extremely high, and for a long time there was
a theory that light could instantaneously reach the most distant points;
in a word, it was considered that the speed of light is infinite. Galileo
was the first who tried to find it experimentally, but without success.
The first person who succeeded in approximately determining the speed of
light, by observing the eclipse of the first satellite of Jupiter in 1675,
was Olaf Römer.
Because of the high speed of light, it is difficult to follow, examine,
and therefore understand all phenomena connected to its behavior. Light's
motion is wavelike in nature as is sound. These two natural phenomena have
a lot in common, for example: propagation (plane and spherical wave), interference,
the Doppler effect, refraction, reflection etc. The speed of sound in the
air is about 9·105 times lower than the speed of light. That is why
it is much easier to perceive, follow and measure certain phenomena present
in sound rather than in light.
Therefore, in order to understand with ease some phenomena connected with the light
and treated by the theory of special relativity it should, at first, to consider
the propagation of sound in the air, and to compare it with the propagation of light
in a vacuum.
Let us assume that at a point in the homogeneous air environment there
is a sinusoidal oscillator whose oscillation generates a spherical sound
wave. If the oscillation of the oscillator is given by equation
![]() |
(3.1) |
where
is elongation,
is amplitude,
is circular frequency and
is time, then the sound waves generated,
when observed at any point on the sphere with a radius
, is defined
by the equation
![]() |
(3.2) |
where
is the radius of the sphere of the observed spherical
wave and
is the velocity of sound in the air. If the environment
is homogeneous then the propagation of the wave will be equal in all directions,
but for the purposes of observation it is enough to take just one direction.
Then Eq. (3.2) becomes
![]() |
(3.3) |
Propagation of the spherical sound wave is given by the following equation
![]() |
(3.4) |
that is
![]() |
(3.5) |
and the propagation of the plane wave along the
-axis
by the following equation
![]() |
(3.6) |
The Eqs. (3.2), (3.3), (3.5) and (3.6) can be applied to light waves
by the following meaning of the values. The elongation
would
present a disturbance of the electric or magnetic waves since they are
mutually conjugated. Amplitude
presents the amplitude of the
electric or magnetic wave. In this case the circular frequency
has
the same meaning, while
would be the speed of light instead
of the speed of sound.
We should pay especial attention to the Eqs. (3.4), (3.5) and (3.6),
because they were used to derive the Lorentz transformation whose aim was
to prove the contraction of the body moving through an ether and to explain
the negative result of Michelson's experiment. Really, the above stated
equations were treated as equations which describe electromagnetic wave
motion, instead of sound wave motion. In considering the fact that these
equations have the same form both for the light and sound wave propagation
it is justifiable to state that the special theory of relativity can be
derived on the basis of sound propagation instead of on the base of light
propagation. In the special theory of relativity it is stated that there
is no higher speed than the speed of light, not even the relative speed.
It was the same with sound. A lot of time, effort and knowledge were required
to break through the "sound barrier". For a long time it was considered
impossible. Many had stated that an aircraft would simply fall apart on
reaching such a speed. In spite of this many aircraft of different dimensions
have broken that sound barrier carrying heavy loads. Now many state that
there is no way of breaking through the "electromagnetic barrier", that
is to obtain a speed higher than the speed of light in vacuum. It is debatable
whether that statement is based upon the facts or incomplete and approximate
mathematical equations. Has it not, in fact, been broken by the distant
quasars, that, judging by their red shift, are moving away from us at three
times the speed of light [16]?
Sound velocity propagation does not depend on the speed of motion of
the sound source. The same occurs in the case of the propagation of light.
However, in certain circumstances the velocity of sound can be higher or
lower than in the open air.
Let us suppose that the sound source is located at the origin of an
unmoving coordinate system
(Fig.3.1) and let us say that a
closed car moves in a straight line, along the
-axis
at speed
.
The sound pulse, generated at the origin of the system
reaches
the moving closed car after some time and passes trough the back wall into
the air inside. From that moment the sound in the car moves from the back
of the car to the front at speed
in relation to the back wall
of the car. In relation to the sound source in the coordinate system
,
from which it originated, this sound is now moving at speed
,
where
is the speed of the car,
and with it also the speed of air which carries
the sound. In that way the sound velocity in relation to the source can
be up to almost two times higher. If the car moves in the opposite direction
to that of the sound, then the sound velocity in the car relative to the
source would be
. This occurs because the closed car carries medium
- particles of air, whose oscillations transfer sound. If the car is open
this phenomenon does not occur, and the sound is propagated at the same
speed as in the surrounding open space independently of the speed and direction
of motion of the open car. In a closed car or an airplane, whose speed
may be higher than the speed of sound, the passengers can have a normal
conversation and the speed of motion has no influence on the propagation
of the sound inside the car or plane, because the particles, that transfer
the sound by oscillation, are carried inside the closed space. If it where
an open car traveling at supersonic speed then the particles would not
be carried and the sound from the back part of that open car would not
reach the front part.
For example, it is well known that a sound of a jet stays behind the jet
when the speed of the jet is higher than the speed of sound.
![]() |
A similar situation could occur with light if there were a medium whose
oscillations transfer light, and if this medium could be contained and
carried. This medium could, for example, be tied to earth, in which case
earth would carry it along, rotate with it on the way round the sun, and
move together with the sun through cosmos. This is the case with, for example,
the magnetic field of earth. Likewise it could also be the case for the
earth's ether. If that where so, then the speed of light in relation to
its source (star) could be higher than 300000 km/sec, and many phenomena
such as, for example, aberration would be logical and clear. At all events
this idea cannot be excluded.
home